Back to Insights
Insight | Executive Search

A CV is not everything. What really matters in key appointments?

Anita Lavrini on why the most impressive CV does not necessarily mean the right choice, and what really makes the difference in the Executive Search process.

Expert commentary · Anita Lavrini, HEAD OF STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIPS AND EXECUTIVE SEARCH CONSULTANT · 10 May 2026 · Executive Search

To watch the Google Drive video, please allow functional cookies.

Open the video on Google Drive
Video: A CV is not everything — Anita Lavrini, FirstClass.

How many outstanding candidates do companies overlook simply because their CV does not look ‘perfect’? In Executive Search, we encounter this question on almost every project. The answer often surprises even experienced owners and management boards.

Why the best CV is not always the best choice

In Executive Search, we often encounter the belief that the strongest CV also means the strongest candidate. In practice, the picture is far more nuanced. An impressive CV tells us what someone has done, but not how they did it, with whom or in what environment.

Key appointments are not a reward for a past career. They are a decision about the company's future. That is why we do not look for the candidate with the longest list of job titles, but for the person who will contribute most at the organisation's particular stage of development.

Fit with the company's culture and stage of development

A company growing rapidly needs a different leader from one consolidating or reshaping its business model. The same role can have entirely different requirements in different contexts.

Our assessment therefore considers not only the substance of previous roles, but also the circumstances: what the organisation was like, what challenges it faced, which decisions the candidate actually made and where they merely contributed. This context often explains why the same biography on paper can translate into very different results in practice.

Potential matters more than the past

The past is an important indicator, but it only tells us about what we have already seen. For key roles, we are more interested in the capacity to make future decisions that we cannot yet anticipate than in a person's track record alone.

That is why, in our conversations, we carefully explore how candidates think, how they learn from mistakes, how they make difficult decisions and how they build relationships with the people they lead. These are precisely the answers a CV never provides.

Candidates a conventional filter would overlook

In our experience, some of the most successful appointments are often people who would not have passed an initial keyword filter. Someone with experience in a different industry, an unconventional career path or a longer gap between roles can, in the right context, bring exactly what an organisation needs.

An Executive Search consultant's job is not to confirm the obvious. It is to draw attention to candidates an internal process would not have found, and to explain, with evidence, why each deserves serious consideration.

What this means for owners and management boards

If you select people for key appointments solely on their CVs, you are choosing from a much smaller pool than you think. Real insight only emerges when you place a candidate in your company's specific strategic situation and ask what decisions they would make and why.

The right choice is always a combination of expertise, values, motivation and cultural fit. A CV is the starting point for a conversation, not the answer to it.

Conversation

Planning a key appointment?

If you are preparing to appoint someone to a key role, let's talk. We discuss questions about the profile, candidates and the Executive Search process confidentially.

Confidential · Evidence-based · Focused

Back to Insights

Explore our other insights, practical examples and conversations.

Insights