Back to Insights
Article | Executive Search

Cognitive bias in recruitment

Article · FirstClass blog · 5 May 2023 · Executive Search

Written by:

Jelka Špende
Senior HR Consultant

Interested in how HR professionals make decisions during a job interview?

This was also the question that interested a group of researchers from three universities who, in 2015, studied how HR professionals decide which candidate to select. What they discovered was surprising. Their research showed that as many as 60% make their decision within the first 15 minutes of an interview, while 20% of the HR professionals surveyed do so within the first five minutes.

The reasons for such hasty decisions can also be found in our brains. During evolution, the human brain developed convenient mental shortcuts that simplify judgement and decision-making. These are involuntary, automatic responses based on past experience, stereotypes and prejudices rather than objective facts, and they can affect various aspects of our lives. We call this cognitive bias (cognitive bias), and it influences how we subjectively understand, interpret and remember information. Essentially, it is an adaptive function of the brain, which tends to use mental shortcuts to make decision-making easier when information is lacking. Problems arise when we have enough information to make a decision, yet still unintentionally resort to rapid, biased decision-making.

We have all encountered various forms of cognitive bias in everyday life. One well-known example is the ‘bandwagon’ effect, which refers to believing something because many other people believe it. The likelihood that someone believes something increases with the number of people who support it. Think of a popular diet, dietary supplement or fashion trend. People often follow the crowd without asking whether what they are doing makes sense or benefits them.

In everyday life, we often see bias in favour of members of our own social group (for example, an ethnic, social or national group), which has also been confirmed by numerous studies. People have a proven cognitive bias towards ‘their own’, which, in its extreme form, can lead not only to stereotypical perceptions of other groups, but also to hostility and aggression towards them.

Cognitive bias in selection processes

The aim of selection processes is to choose the most suitable candidate for the position. Yet candidates are sometimes treated unequally, with HR professionals favouring or rejecting them precisely because of their cognitive biases. This is the tendency for individuals to (unconsciously) select certain candidates based on personal preferences or prejudices rather than objective factors. In practice, we can identify various types of bias relating to gender, race, appearance, nationality or age.

Yale University conducted a study involving 127 scientists who were sent identical candidate CVs, with gender as the only variable. The researchers found that participants selecting for a leadership position more frequently chose the male candidate’s CV and also offered him a higher salary.

The Employment Relationships Act stipulates that vacancies must not be advertised exclusively for women or exclusively for men, and that job adverts must not suggest that the employer favours one gender when hiring. In practice, however, indirect gender discrimination remains fairly common.

Common types of bias

There are several types of cognitive bias. The following are among the most common:

1. The halo effect occurs when a candidate’s positive qualities are generalised to their entire personality, while their negative qualities are overlooked. An HR consultant might therefore choose a particular candidate solely because of their well-known name or because they attended a prestigious university, while giving less weight to other factors.

2. Bias against those who are different appears in selection processes when a recruiter chooses a candidate based on personal prejudices and stereotypes about a particular group of people. For example, an employer may reject a candidate because of their nationality or sexual orientation. Dr Cory Clark, a psychologist at the University of Pennsylvania, attributes this type of bias to our prehistoric development. Humans evolved in small groups that, throughout history, encountered other such groups and often fought them for land and resources. The most successful groups – those that coordinated and cooperated well – passed their genes on to modern humans. Social psychology shows that people quickly recognise members of their own group and treat them better than members of an outside or opposing group.

3. The contrast effect occurs when the sole basis for a decision is comparison with previous (potentially unsuitable) candidates, rather than objective criteria. This can lead us to choose the ‘best of a bad bunch’.

4. Similarity bias is an error of judgement that results in selecting a candidate who resembles the recruiter in personality, interests and education.

5. Another common bias is first-impression bias, where we judge a candidate on their first impression rather than their suitability for the role. Sometimes a candidate’s CV may make them look ideal for a position, but their appearance in a face-to-face interview may put us off (or attract us).

Ways to limit and avoid cognitive bias in recruitment

1. Assessment against objective criteria

Using objective criteria, such as suitability for the role, competencies, education and work experience, to assess candidates. This reduces the likelihood of judgements based on personal preferences and prejudices.

2. Using structured interviews

Structured interviews are an interviewing method based on predetermined questions that are the same for all candidates. This reduces the likelihood of employers asking biased or inappropriate questions.

3. Awareness of your own biases

Everyone who works with people should be aware of the burden of their own biases. These can be overcome through appropriate training and self-reflection.

4. Using reference checks

Reference checks are also useful in reducing bias, as employers can obtain objective information about candidates from previous employers.

5. Using artificial intelligence or selection tools

These tools anonymise some of the candidate’s personal information (such as gender) with the aim of eliminating bias.

6. Diversity, equality and inclusion

As values that should be nurtured within the company, creating a culture in which employees feel accepted.

7. Choosing an external HR partner for recruitment

HR companies and agencies carry out selection processes daily, using objective methods and analysis to select the right candidate.

Because of the human factor, recruitment bias can never be eliminated entirely, but we can use various tools to limit it as much as possible. Impartial candidate selection reflects a company’s culture and is essential to ensuring inclusion and synergy within a diverse and competitive workforce.

Choosing an HR partner for recruitment is also an effective way to limit bias when selecting a future colleague. We will be happy to help and ensure that candidates are not treated differently because of bias during the process. Email us at info@first-class.si and we will be happy to help!